22 Comments
User's avatar
Rio Santos's avatar

Kassie, my queen, do you have any tips on adding EVOO to buttercream? Should it replace some of the butter or are you just adding to the base recipe as flavor 🧐

Expand full comment
Kassie Mendieta's avatar

don't replace any of the butter with olive oil! You'll actaully treat the olive oil more like a flavor extract and add it to your buttercream to add a little flavor :) if ya swapped it for butter you'd lose the structure that the butter is giving!

Expand full comment
Rio Santos's avatar

Making tons and tons of the stuff rn thank you 🫶🏼

Expand full comment
Tulsi Anna's avatar

Kassie, how would you suggest going about adding coconut? full fat milk? extract? thank you!! <3

Expand full comment
Kassie Mendieta's avatar

I'd def go coconut extract/emulsion here! I think adding the coconut milk might add too much liquid and cause the buttercream to break!

Expand full comment
Marcela Magaña's avatar

hi! I’m going to use this recipe soon but i wanted to ask you do you think 5 cups is still enough for a 3 layered 9 inch cake? the internet says so but I wanted to consult with the chef 😅😂

Expand full comment
Kassie Mendieta's avatar

hi!! Yeah, it should be plenty for a 9" cake. Especially if you fill the cake with another type of filling and just use the buttercream for the outside + decor (-: It ultimately comes down to how you build your cake and how much you put between the layers, everyones preferences are different. If ur still feeling anxious about having enough you can always do a 1.5x batch and any left over freezes perfectly!

Expand full comment
Marcela Magaña's avatar

thank you so much! really excite to try this recipe 🥹

Expand full comment
Bevvvvrly's avatar

I just made this - I have made swiss buttercream only a dozen or so times as a casual baker and I just want to rave that it tastes amazing and it was the first time I didn’t once question my choice to make my own buttercream! Thank you!

Expand full comment
Amy Zone's avatar

Kassie, I’m doing a large sheet cake for 50 people. I think I need to make a triple batch of this so I can pipe and frost. Any suggestions on getting a double batch same consistency?

Expand full comment
Kassie Mendieta's avatar

Hey Amy!

You should be able to follow the same methodology as making a single time batch to get the same consistency. It should actually be easier now, with more buttercream covering the paddle. At most it might just take a few minutes longer than a single batch to get similar consistency :) Best of luck with your sheet cake!

Expand full comment
Callie geringer's avatar

Hello! How long do to u recommend waiting to add in the butter? I’m not sure why but my buttercream separated last time I tried :(

Expand full comment
Kassie Mendieta's avatar

hey! whipping the whites is not based on time rather keeping an eye out for stiff peaks and a meringue that has cooled down to room temp, which the time for both of these can vary based on so many factors. if it separates in a way that looks like cottage cheese your butter might have been too cold, you just need to whip it until it emulsifies back into a lush frosting :)

Expand full comment
Teresa Villegaz's avatar

Do you happen to have the measurements in cups ?

Expand full comment
Kassie Mendieta's avatar

no i do not, my recipes are only offered with weight measurements

Expand full comment
Amisha Palmer's avatar

Hi! qq: are you using boxed egg whites in this recipe or fresh egg whites?

Expand full comment
Kassie Mendieta's avatar

i use fresh but in a pinch have used boxed and it works just as well though the whites don’t whip AS stiff. not the end of the world tho!

Expand full comment
Amisha Palmer's avatar

Awesome, thank you so much :)

Expand full comment
Mila's avatar

Hi! I’m so excited to try this recipe. What speed should be used to beat the buttercream in steps 5, 6, and 7? Thank you

Expand full comment
avi's avatar

hi! love your content so muchhh!! i have a question tho… could i somehow replace honey for some of the sugar or somehow flavor it with honey? ty! 🩵

Expand full comment
Taisha Hodes's avatar

What would you say is the “normal” amount of salt? I was looking for an approximate of what most people use.

Expand full comment
Kassie Mendieta's avatar

I would say for me I add about a 2 teaspoons to a tablespoon worth of salt to this recipe but I also mostly eyeball it so sometimes a touch more. rarely ever less. Though im not sure I fall under the "normal" category as I am a SALT LOVER

Expand full comment